Book Review: Girl Online


Girl Online- Zoe Sugg
By now, everybody knows that Zoella's novel was ghostwritten and that the ghostwriter is Siobhan Curham, so this will be a strange review to write. For clarity, I will just use the phrase "the author", rather than deciding which of the two names to reference. 

Girl Online is not an autobiographical text, but the protagonist is a successful young Brighton-based blogger suffering from anxiety. Unlike Zoe, Penny chooses to blog anonymously with only her gay best friend (we'll get on to that in a moment) knowing the truth behind her identity. When the family travel to New York at Christmas, she meets a "Rock-God-tastic" musician named Noah and quickly falls in love. The only problem is, Noah has a (very predictable) secret and the truth will soon come out about Penny's true identity.

To be honest, I'm not the target demographic of Girl Online, so I wasn't expecting to be blown away, although I did read it with an open mind. It wasn't a bad novel in terms of teenage romance fiction and exactly what you would expect- Light, fluffy and predictable with teenage angst and a happy ending. The writing was not awful and there was one moment that made me laugh out loud (it involved a pebble and a dog on the beach). 

However, the problems I had with the novel are threefold: The horrendously two-dimensional characters, the inaccurate and improbable internet references, and the misrepresentation of anxiety.
Penny is a supposedly quirky, impossibly clumsy and awkward teenage girl, a clich├ęd characteristic of any modern protagonist. She likes fairy lights, candles and bath bombs because...awkward teenage girl. Her BFIS (best friend in school, apparently) is Megan, a vacuous, bitchy queen bee who seemingly lives to sabotage everything Penny does, yet still remains her friend. Noah is a cool, modelesque rock star who buys creepy china dolls as a gift and was orphaned after both parents died in a skiing accident, and Penny's family are ridiculously welcoming, even taking her best friend Elliot to New York at Christmas. However, Elliot was the sticking point for me. He is Penny's gay best friend (because what's cooler than using somebody's sexuality as an accessory?) who squeals, jumps in the air, claps his hands together in excitement and throws milkshakes over people. Of course his fashion sense is amazing and he loves Beyonce. Honestly, I have to say I found this overt stereotyping offensive and it does nothing to chip away at preconceived ideas of gay men.

In terms of the inaccuracies, there were some very confusing events that seemed to hint at somebody who is not too aware of how blogging pans out in reality. For example, Penny wrote a post about falling over and gained 800 followers overnight. If only that were possible! Noah turns out to be (spoiler alert) the hottest musical sensation who Megan (Penny's BFIS, remember?) fancies, yet Penny has absolutely no idea who he is. Surely if she was a successful blogger, she would have an understanding of popular youth culture on the internet? Then there are all the clumsy references to Brighton landmarks which just makes me think the author typed in "things to do in Brighton" and squeezed in as many as possible. 

Finally, we come on to the anxiety issue. Penny experiences panic attacks and opens up about them online as she cannot face telling anybody in real life. I completely understand this and it's one of the more believable aspects of Penny's character. Until she goes to New York, meets Noah and suddenly everything is ok. Phew! Glad we've found a cure for anxiety!
Although Girl Online does address some powerful issues, I wish they'd been more carefully researched in order to be portrayed realistically. Having said that, there are some strong messages, particularly at the end of the novel when Penny realises that she can't hide from her online scandal and instead faces up to it. I fully support the message that girls should confront their fears in order to defeat them. Overall, while not the best book I've ever read, it's certainly not terrible in terms of the target demographic.

13 comments:

  1. there seems to be a lot controversy going on for this book. I wasn't looking forward to read it but this sudden issue made me curious to know more. It's really typical but teen-ish.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Right, I'm off to dump my boyfriend because he hasn't cured my anxiety yet!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have not bought or read the book but what you describe about the anxiety issues of the main character and that its all solved after she meet this one guy makes me angry. Surely somebody who deals themselves with anxiety should have know better or atleast when she did not write it herself, have intervened when she read it. Or if you do not feel like portraying it correctly, maybe for go it completely? I do not expect more from the general media but more from somebody who likes to be seen as an ambassador for mental illness.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's interesting Penny learns to come clean and faces up to her online scandal. I wonder if Zoe will reflect this once she breaks her silence on the issue!
    Megan (not vacuous, bitchy or a queen bee) x
    London Callings

    ReplyDelete
  5. I couldn't agree more with this review. Like you I'm not the target demographic, if I was a 14 year old young girl I might have loved it. I sometimes felt like it might have been written in a rushed manner because of the inaccuracies. The ideas and messages are there but it was not thought out as well as it could have been.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the honest review! All the ones I have read so far have either just been like yay zoella it's so amazing, or this is a terrible childish book, so it is good to get a balanced opinion! x

    http://www.bloglovin.com/blog/12113865

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow finally a review. I've seen all these blog posts about the ghostwriting but none about the actual book. Doesn't sound like my cup of tea really and hardly progressive. The fact that the protagonist gets better once she meets a boy seems highly old-fashioned. Sounds like it's full of stereotypes and cliches, its a shame as Zoella really had an opportunity to write something progressive and reach out to all her younger females and speak out about empowerment, but clearly not...

    Great post Becky :)

    The Makeup Directory

    ReplyDelete
  8. Doesn't really sound like something I would want to read to be honest but like you I am not in the target demographic. Nice to get an in depth review of it though, thanks!

    Emma | frillsanddoodads.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you for saving me the time and money on this book! I thought it would be an autobiography of Zoe and her personal journey from blogger to Youtuber to rising star. What it turned out to be doesn't seem like something that would keep me interested and I'm SO thankful somebody gave an honest review of it! Thanks Becky!
    ~ Samantha

    ReplyDelete
  10. Was very interested to read your reivew of this book, I haven't read any other reviews so far. I don't think I am the target audience either but I enjoyed reading what you thought of it and I think you raise some good points. x

    ReplyDelete
  11. I saw the list of 10 things about Anxiety in the book and i was totally disgusted, how she can portay a mental health issue like a walk in the park is beyond me. I completely agree with everything you said, i just wish it was written better.
    Love Vicki <3 victoriajanex.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great review. I'm not going to read this book as it's really not the kind of book that massively appeals to me, but after hearing all of the hype (both around Zoella and the ghostwriter) I wanted to know what it was about and if it was any cop. And I've got to be honest, I wanted to know what the twist was! So thank you - you've summed it up perfectly, saved me lots of time and £5 :) x

    ReplyDelete
  13. I was checking this book out in case it would suit my 13 year old, but it doesn't sound like a good book.
    She loves Cathy Cassidy and those ones about "Angus, thongs and snogging" so I think she's the target audience!

    ReplyDelete

I read all comments and appreciate every single one, even if I can't always reply. If you have a question or need a reply, feel free to tweet me @BeckyBedbug- I always reply to tweets!